Sarita's Pastas & Pizza: Long Bay Village's Hidden Italian-Caribbean Kitchen
Homemade pizzas and fresh pastas served with island warmth in a tiny Long Bay hideaway.
Why Go
Tucked into the quiet neighborhood of Long Bay Village, Sarita's is the kind of unassuming, family-run spot where the pizza dough is scented with seven herbs from the garden out back and the owner remembers what you ordered last time. It's not on the beach, it's not fancy, and that's exactly why Anguilla regulars keep coming back.
The Experience
Pull up to a modest little building far from the resort strip and you'll find a cozy outdoor patio with a handful of tables, the smell of oven-fresh dough drifting out, and Sarita herself often working the room. Locals grab pies to go and take them back to their yards; visitors settle in for a slow, casual dinner that feels more like eating at a friend's home than at a restaurant. The vibe is warm, unhurried, and refreshingly unpolished ΓÇö a welcome contrast to Anguilla's white-tablecloth beach clubs. Expect generous portions, fair prices, and a menu that quietly rotates with whatever's fresh from the garden.
What to Try
Order **The Anguillian** ΓÇö Sarita's signature pizza loaded with local fish, shrimp, spinach, peppers, onions, tomatoes, olives, and zucchini on that herb-scented crust. It's the dish that tells the whole story of this place. If you're a pasta person, the **fettuccine Alfredo** and classic **spaghetti marinara** are done properly, and the **daily pasta special** (ask when you sit down) is usually the kitchen showing off. Save room for a **homemade dessert** ΓÇö they change often and are consistently better than they need to be.
Insider Tip
The best move is to call ahead (+1 264-729-4252) and order for pickup, especially on busy nights when the tiny patio fills fast. If you're renting a villa, this is one of the smartest takeout dinners on the island ΓÇö the pizzas travel beautifully. And don't skip the daily specials board; the regulars-only items are where Sarita's really shines.
The Practical Stuff
Location: Long Bay Village (plus code 5VPC+XMC), inland from the west-end beaches ΓÇö a short drive from Meads Bay, Barnes Bay, and Shoal Bay West. Price range: budget-friendly to moderate; expect casual, cash-and-card, no dress code. Seating is limited to a small outdoor patio, so takeout is a popular option. Hours vary ΓÇö call ahead to confirm, and note that many Anguilla kitchens close between lunch and dinner service.
Pair It With
- Meads Bay — Spend the afternoon on one of Anguilla's most beautiful powdery-sand beaches, then swing inland to Sarita's for a laid-back dinner without changing out of your beach clothes.
- Shoal Bay West Guide — After a quiet snorkel or sunset walk on this less-crowded west-end beach, Sarita's is one of the closest and most character-filled dinner options.
- 20 Knots — Stay nearby at this Long BayΓÇôarea property and make Sarita's your reliable neighborhood dinner ΓÇö an easy walk or short drive for pizza night.
- Heritage Collection Museum — Pair a morning of Anguillian history and culture with a genuine local dinner spot that reflects the island's community-first food scene.